Monk lowers his own bread down a cliff to St. Benedict
Only one monk knew where the young Saint Benedict hid for three years, and he kept the bread coming after a stone smashed his bell.

About this picture
AI-generated image, in the manner of Italian buon fresco on lime plaster, from the paper's reference portrait based on Come Benedetto abbandona la scuola di Roma (Life of St Benedict, Scene 2: Benedict Leaves the School in Rome) (Il Sodoma (Giovanni Antonio Bazzi), 1505-1508 AD, Great cloister, Abbazia di Monte Oliveto Maggiore, Asciano, Siena) View source artwork.
SUBIACO, Roman Italy, about 500 AD — Every so often, a little bell rang outside a cave in a cliff in the hills of Italy. Then a loaf of bread came swinging down on a very long rope.
The young man living in the cave was Saint Benedict of Nursia. It was about 500 AD, at a wild place called Subiaco, forty miles from Rome. Only one person in the world knew he was there: the monk holding the other end of the rope.
St. Benedict had given up his studies in Rome to give his whole life to God. He wanted to live as far from people as he could.
The cave he picked was only about ten feet deep. He could cross it in a few steps. Its opening was a big triangle. Above it the mountain went almost straight up. Below it, the ground dropped about 500 feet to a lake. That’s about as far as a building of forty floors is tall.
The monk at the top of the rope
On his way to Subiaco, St. Benedict met a monk called Saint Romanus on the road. St. Romanus asked him where he was going. Once St. Romanus understood what St. Benedict meant to do, he kept it a secret. He gave St. Benedict a monk’s habit to wear and helped him in every way he could.
St. Romanus lived with other monks in a monastery on the mountain, right above the cliff where the cave was. The monastery had its own abbot. But there was no path down to the cave, because a high rock stuck out over it.
St. Romanus found another way. On certain days he slipped away without his abbot noticing, to take St. Benedict his bread. The bread wasn’t spare. It was the loaf the monastery had given St. Romanus for his own meals.
He tied the loaf to a long rope and let it down from the top of the rock. He tied a little bell to the rope, too. Pope Saint Gregory the Great wrote down St. Benedict’s life. St. Gregory gives the reason for the bell: “that by the ringing thereof the man of God might know when he came with his bread, and so be ready to take it.” When the bell rang, St. Benedict came out of the cave. He took the loaf off the rope.
The day the bell broke
One day a loaf was on its way down. A stone came flying and smashed the bell. St. Gregory writes that the devil threw it. He calls the devil “the old enemy of mankind.” The devil was jealous, St. Gregory says, of St. Romanus’s kindness and of the food St. Benedict was getting. St. Romanus didn’t stop. St. Gregory writes: “for all that, Romanus gave not over to serve him by all the possible means he could.”
St. Romanus fed St. Benedict like this for all three years St. Benedict lived hidden in the cave. Then, St. Gregory writes, God decided “to ease Romanus of his pains.” On Easter Day, Our Lord appeared to a priest who lived a long way off. The priest had just got his Easter dinner ready. Our Lord told him that one of His servants was going hungry in a certain place. The priest took the food, searched the steep hills and valleys, and found St. Benedict in his cave.
About this story
Catholic Saints News tells the lives of the saints as news from their own time and place. This story was written with AI from the historical record, and we read and approved it before it ran.
The Saints' words. This newspaper will never make a saint say something the historical record does not preserve.
Junior Report. Written for readers ten to twelve, from the same sources and under the same rules as the rest of the paper. The words are shorter, hard terms are explained, and the question at the end is for the reader to think over.
Read more
- · Gregory the Great, Dialogues, Book II: The Life of St Benedict, Chapter One (Tertullian Project)
- · Hugh Ford, 'St. Benedict of Nursia', The Catholic Encyclopedia (New Advent)
Image. AI-generated image, in the manner of Italian buon fresco on lime plaster, from the paper's reference portrait based on Come Benedetto abbandona la scuola di Roma (Life of St Benedict, Scene 2: Benedict Leaves the School in Rome) (Il Sodoma (Giovanni Antonio Bazzi), 1505-1508 AD, Great cloister, Abbazia di Monte Oliveto Maggiore, Asciano, Siena) — see the original.
Found an error? Let us know.
Sources for this story
Listed by paragraph.
- Paragraph 1
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; Latin text as transcribed on Wikisource, Dialogi, Liber II (Gregorius Magnus) - Latin text, Wikisource
- Paragraph 2
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- documented Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience of 9 April 2008: Saint Benedict of Norcia, GENERAL AUDIENCE ¶6
- attested Rev. Alban Butler, The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs and Other Principal Saints, vol. III: March — 21 March, St Benedict, Abbot, MARCH XXI., p. 274 ¶9
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶12
- attested Francis Mershman, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: Subiaco, ¶10
- documented Pope Pius XII, Fulgens Radiatur (Encyclical of Pope Pius XII on St Benedict, for the fourteenth centenary of his death), ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS XII ¶8
- attested Luigi Tosti, O.S.B., abbot and archivist of Monte Cassino, Della vita di San Benedetto: discorso storico, CAPO II, p. 4 ¶15
- attested New Catholic Encyclopedia (2nd ed.), reproduced at Encyclopedia.com, New Catholic Encyclopedia: Subiaco, Monasteries of, ¶11
- attested Monastero di San Benedetto (Sacro Speco), Subiaco, Monastero di San Benedetto - Sacro Speco, Subiaco: the monastery, ¶7
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶2
- attested Paul the Deacon; trans. William Dudley Foulke, History of the Langobards, Book I (chapter 26 on St Benedict), Chapter XXVI., p. 47 ¶1
- Paragraph 3
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, The Second Book
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶2
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶11
- Paragraph 4
- Paragraph 5
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶2
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶12
- attested Rev. Alban Butler, The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs and Other Principal Saints, vol. III: March — 21 March, St Benedict, Abbot, MARCH XXI., p. 274 ¶9
- attested Francis Mershman, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: Subiaco, ¶10
- documented Catholic Church, Liturgy and Ritual; ed. Archbishop of Baltimore, The Roman Martyrology, translated from the fourth edition after the typical edition of 1914, I T Corinth, the birthday of the holy martyrs Callis-, p. 10 ¶123
- attested Luigi Tosti, O.S.B., abbot and archivist of Monte Cassino, Della vita di San Benedetto: discorso storico, CAPO II, p. 35 ¶3
- attested Luigi Tosti, O.S.B., abbot and archivist of Monte Cassino, Della vita di San Benedetto: discorso storico, CAPO II, p. 4 ¶10
- Paragraph 6
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶12
- attested Michael Ott, Catholic Encyclopedia: Sts. Romanus (section 6, St Romanus of Subiaco), ¶14
- attested Luigi Tosti, O.S.B., abbot and archivist of Monte Cassino, Della vita di San Benedetto: discorso storico, CAPO II, p. 4 ¶18
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- Paragraph 7
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; Latin text as transcribed on Wikisource, Dialogi, Liber II (Gregorius Magnus) - Latin text, Wikisource
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶12
- attested Michael Ott, Catholic Encyclopedia: Sts. Romanus (section 6, St Romanus of Subiaco), ¶14
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- attested Rev. Alban Butler, The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs and Other Principal Saints, vol. III: March — 21 March, St Benedict, Abbot, MARCH XXI., p. 274 ¶9
- Paragraph 8
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; Latin text as transcribed on Wikisource, Dialogi, Liber II (Gregorius Magnus) - Latin text, Wikisource
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶9
- documented Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience of 9 April 2008: Saint Benedict of Norcia, GENERAL AUDIENCE ¶4
- Paragraph 9
- Paragraph 10
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶3
- attested Rev. Alban Butler, The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs and Other Principal Saints, vol. III: March — 21 March, St Benedict, Abbot, MARCH XXI., p. 274 ¶9
- attested Hugh Ford, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: St. Benedict of Nursia, ¶12
- attested Francis Mershman, O.S.B., Catholic Encyclopedia: Subiaco, ¶10
- documented Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience of 9 April 2008: Saint Benedict of Norcia, GENERAL AUDIENCE ¶6
- documented Pope Pius XII, Fulgens Radiatur (Encyclical of Pope Pius XII on St Benedict, for the fourteenth centenary of his death), ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS XII ¶8
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One ¶4
- documented Pope St. Gregory the Great; trans. 'P.W.' (Paris, 1608), re-edited by Edmund G. Gardner (1911), Dialogues, Book Two: Of the Life and Miracles of St Benedict, Chapter One: how he made a ¶4
- attested Luigi Tosti, O.S.B., abbot and archivist of Monte Cassino, Della vita di San Benedetto: discorso storico
