Settle your quarrel first, the emperor's letter said
Bishops at a council in Tyre were told to settle their quarrel, then hurry to Jerusalem for two new churches.

About this picture
AI-generated image, in the manner of a late-Roman fresco of the Constantinian decades, from the paper's reference portrait based on Christ enthroned between the apostles Peter and Paul, with the Lamb on the hill of the four rivers and the martyrs Gorgonius, Peter, Marcellinus and Tiburtius (Unknown Roman painter, 4th century AD, Catacomb of Saints Marcellinus and Peter, Via Labicana, Rome) View source artwork.
JERUSALEM, Roman Palestine, September 13, 335 AD — Marianus, the Emperor Constantine’s shorthand notary, walked into a meeting of bishops at Tyre, in Phoenicia. He handed over a letter. The bishops had been called there to settle a quarrel among the churches of Egypt. The letter told them to leave for Jerusalem at once and consecrate a church.
It also told them to sort their own quarrel out before they went. Constantine wanted every argument settled and all the bad feeling cleared away. Men who were fighting each other had no business bringing a gift to God.
One of the churches stands at Golgotha, the little hill where the Lord was crucified. The people of Jerusalem call it the Great Martyrium. The other stands about a stone’s throw away. It is built over the crypt where the Lord’s body was laid, and from which he rose on the third day. That one is called the Anastasis, and the word means the Resurrection.
The temple built on top of the tomb
St. Helena, the emperor’s mother, came to Palestine in 326 AD. She was nearly eighty. She found the old city deserted. The tomb of Christ lay buried under a mound of earth, with a temple of Venus standing on top of it. Enemies of the faith had put the temple there so that people would stop honouring the tomb.
St. Helena ordered the temple pulled down and the earth carried away. The tomb was there underneath. According to longstanding Catholic tradition, three crosses were found buried near it. Everyone there held it as certain that one of them was the Cross of the Lord, and the other two the crosses of the thieves crucified with him. She died in 330 AD, before the buildings were finished.
Her son had ordered them built on a scale to match the place. Writing to St. Macarius, the bishop of Jerusalem, Constantine said the church must be “incomparably superior to the most beautiful structures in every city throughout the world.” The Great Martyrium was finished in about the thirtieth year of Constantine’s reign. There was a festival that year for those thirty years, and he picked it as the right moment to have the church consecrated.
Bishops from Persia to Libya
Bishops travelled from Persia, from Thrace, from Cappadocia, from Egypt and from Libya. Monks came from the Thebaid, and crowds from every province followed them. An escort from the emperor went with them, and officers sent from the palace had orders to make the festival grander still. Constantine paid for it. Bishop Eusebius of Caesarea, who came for the day, called it the biggest gathering he knew of after the council at Nicaea ten years ago.
Constantine did not come to Jerusalem. Marianus welcomed the bishops in his place. He gave them somewhere to stay and fed them at banquets. He handed out money and clothing to people who had nothing, and food to men and women who had been going without. The emperor sent costly ornaments and gifts of his own into the church.
Today the two churches were consecrated to God, and the feast runs on through tomorrow. It was done with prayers and sermons. Some of the bishops spoke about the emperor’s love for the Saviour, and about how grand his building was. Others explained passages of Scripture.
The day was chosen to fall on the day the Cross of the Lord had been found. According to longstanding Catholic tradition, it was found in the digging St. Helena ordered on this same ground nine years ago.
These days became a feast at Jerusalem, kept for eight days. People were baptised during them, and others came from every region under the sun to visit the holy places. The Church keeps September 14, the second of the two days, as the feast of the Exaltation of the Cross.
About this story
Catholic Saints News tells the lives of the saints as news from their own time and place. This story was written with AI from the historical record, and we read and approved it before it ran.
The Saints' words. This newspaper will never make a saint say something the historical record does not preserve.
Junior Report. Written for readers ten to twelve, from the same sources and under the same rules as the rest of the paper. The words are shorter, hard terms are explained, and the question at the end is for the reader to think over.
Read more
- · Egeria, The Pilgrimage of Etheria (c. 381-384 AD; trans. McClure and Feltoe)
- · Fernand Cabrol, 'The True Cross', The Catholic Encyclopedia (1908)
Image. AI-generated image, in the manner of a late-Roman fresco of the Constantinian decades, from the paper's reference portrait based on Christ enthroned between the apostles Peter and Paul, with the Lamb on the hill of the four rivers and the martyrs Gorgonius, Peter, Marcellinus and Tiburtius (Unknown Roman painter, 4th century AD, Catacomb of Saints Marcellinus and Peter, Via Labicana, Rome) — see the original.
Found an error? Let us know.
Sources for this story
Listed by paragraph.
- Paragraph 1
- Paragraph 2
- Paragraph 3
- Paragraph 4
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book III, Chapter 41. Of the Erection of Churches in Bethlehem, and on ¶3
- attested Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Ecclesiastical History I.17: Helena, Mother of the Emperor Constantine — her zeal in the erection of the holy Church, ¶22
- attested Socrates Scholasticus (trans. A. C. Zenos), Church History I.17: The Emperor's mother Helena having come to Jerusalem, searches for and finds the Cross of Christ, and builds a Church, ¶22
- attested Sozomen (trans. Chester D. Hartranft), Ecclesiastical History, Book II (ch. 1-2: the discovery of the Cross; Concerning Helena, the mother of the Emperor), Chapter 1. The Discovery of the Life-Bringing Cross and of t ¶1
- attested Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints, August 18: St. Helen, Empress, CATHOLIC DICTIONARY ¶21
- attested Maurice Hassett, Archaeology of the Cross and Crucifix (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶47
- attested Jan Willem Drijvers, University of Groningen, Helena Augusta (De Imperatoribus Romanis: An Online Encyclopedia of Roman Rulers), ¶60
- documented Metropolitan Cantor Institute, Byzantine Catholic Archeparchy of Pittsburgh, Menaion, 21 May: Our Holy Great Sovereigns Constantine and Helen, Equal to the Apostles, ¶59
- Paragraph 5
- attested Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Ecclesiastical History I.17: Helena, Mother of the Emperor Constantine — her zeal in the erection of the holy Church, ¶23
- attested Socrates Scholasticus (trans. A. C. Zenos), Church History I.17: The Emperor's mother Helena having come to Jerusalem, searches for and finds the Cross of Christ, and builds a Church, ¶22
- attested Socrates Scholasticus (trans. A. C. Zenos), Church History I.17: The Emperor's mother Helena having come to Jerusalem, searches for and finds the Cross of Christ, and builds a Church, ¶23
- attested Maurice Hassett, Archaeology of the Cross and Crucifix (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶47
- documented Constantine, preserved by Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Letter from the Emperor to Macarius, Bishop of Jerusalem, concerning the building of the Holy Church (Ecclesiastical History I.16), ¶22
- documented Anonymous pilgrim of Bordeaux (trans. Andrew S. Jacobs), The Bordeaux Pilgrim (Itinerarium Burdigalense), ¶395
- tradition Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Ecclesiastical History I.17: Helena, Mother of the Emperor Constantine — her zeal in the erection of the holy Church, ¶23
- tradition Socrates Scholasticus (trans. A. C. Zenos), Church History I.17: The Emperor's mother Helena having come to Jerusalem, searches for and finds the Cross of Christ, and builds a Church, ¶23
- tradition Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints, August 18: St. Helen, Empress, CATHOLIC DICTIONARY ¶21
- tradition Maurice Hassett, Archaeology of the Cross and Crucifix (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶47
- tradition Maurice Hassett, Archaeology of the Cross and Crucifix (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶49
- tradition J. P. Kirsch, St. Helena (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 7), ¶11
- tradition Rufinus, followed by Socrates, Sozomen and Theodoret; the Catholic Encyclopedia calls it the legend first recorded by Rufinus, while defending its substance from the testimony of St. Cyril of Jerusalem, St. Ambrose and Silvia of Aquitaine.
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book III, Chapter 46. How she made her Will, and died at the Age of Ei ¶1
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book III, Chapter 43. A Farther Notice of the Churches at Bethlehem. ¶1
- attested J. P. Kirsch, St. Helena (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 7), ¶13
- attested Socrates Scholasticus (trans. A. C. Zenos), Church History I.17: The Emperor's mother Helena having come to Jerusalem, searches for and finds the Cross of Christ, and builds a Church, ¶25
- attested Sozomen (trans. Chester D. Hartranft), Ecclesiastical History, Book II (ch. 1-2: the discovery of the Cross; Concerning Helena, the mother of the Emperor), Chapter 1. The Discovery of the Life-Bringing Cross and of t ¶9
- attested Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Ecclesiastical History I.17: Helena, Mother of the Emperor Constantine — her zeal in the erection of the holy Church, ¶22
- attested Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints, August 18: St. Helen, Empress, CATHOLIC DICTIONARY ¶21
- attested Vatican Museums, Sarcophagus of St. Helena, Sala a Croce Greca, Museo Pio Clementino, ¶97
- attested Jan Willem Drijvers, University of Groningen, Helena Augusta (De Imperatoribus Romanis: An Online Encyclopedia of Roman Rulers), ¶76
- attested Jan Willem Drijvers, University of Groningen, Helena Augusta (De Imperatoribus Romanis: An Online Encyclopedia of Roman Rulers), ¶77
- attested Jan Willem Drijvers, University of Groningen, Helena Augusta (De Imperatoribus Romanis: An Online Encyclopedia of Roman Rulers), ¶78
- Paragraph 6
- documented Constantine, preserved by Theodoret of Cyrus (trans. Blomfield Jackson), Letter from the Emperor to Macarius, Bishop of Jerusalem, concerning the building of the Holy Church (Ecclesiastical History I.16), ¶23
- attested Sozomen (trans. Chester D. Hartranft), Ecclesiastical History, Book II (ch. 1-2: the discovery of the Cross; Concerning Helena, the mother of the Emperor), line 150
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book IV, line 186
- Paragraph 7
- Paragraph 8
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book IV, line 212
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book IV, line 204
- attested Sozomen (trans. Chester D. Hartranft), Ecclesiastical History, Book II (ch. 1-2: the discovery of the Cross; Concerning Helena, the mother of the Emperor), line 150
- Paragraph 9
- documented Egeria (trans. M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe, SPCK 1919), The Pilgrimage of Etheria (Egeria), VIII ¶2
- attested Fernand Cabrol, The True Cross (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶33
- attested Fernand Cabrol, The True Cross (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶34
- documented Egeria (trans. M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe, SPCK 1919), The Pilgrimage of Etheria (Egeria), 5. Wednesday in Holy Week . ¶81
- documented Eusebius of Caesarea (trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson), Life of Constantine, Book IV, line 208
- Paragraph 10
- Paragraph 11
- documented Egeria (trans. M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe, SPCK 1919), The Pilgrimage of Etheria (Egeria), VIII ¶3
- attested Sozomen (trans. Chester D. Hartranft), Ecclesiastical History, Book II (ch. 1-2: the discovery of the Cross; Concerning Helena, the mother of the Emperor), line 150
- attested Fernand Cabrol, The True Cross (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶34
- attested Fernand Cabrol, The True Cross (The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 4), ¶35
